A goal in stoppage time by
Trailing to Zavon Hines' 23rd minute strike for the Hammers, Gary Smith's tenacious side fought manfully in the closing stages and was rewarded when O'Toole dramatically leveled following a goalmouth scramble.
A late withdrawal in the visitor's ranks saw a return to action of former star, Kevin Keen, now reserve team coach at Upton Park.
It was apparent from kick-off that the visitors were intent on avenging last week's three goal drubbing at Dagenham & Redbridge in the reverse fixture, and they deservedly took the lead just after the midway point of the first half.
A terrific run down the left by Kyel Reid ended with a low cross to the edge of the penalty area, where Hines controlled and found the net with a superb finish.
Although the second half was a more evenly contested affair there was few clear cut chances at either end, and West Ham United seemed set for all three points until O'Toole's timely intervention.
Watford 1 | West Ham United 1 |
O'Toole 90 | Hines 23 |
Line-ups | |
Scott Loach | Stephen Bywater |
Marvin McCoy | Robbie Blackwell |
Junior Osborne | Marcel McKie |
John-Joe O'Toole | Bondz Ngala |
Adrian Mariappa | Kevin Keen |
Joseph O'Cearuill (Marvin Homand 46) | Jack Collison |
Claude Senla | Hogan Ephraim |
Ben Gill (Alex Campana 62) | Sekou Baradji |
Elliot Frost | Jack Jeffrey (Ben Hunt 70) |
Joel Grant (Theo Robinson 46) | Zavon Hines |
Michael Bardle | Kyel Reid |
Substitutes not used | |
James Beasant | Junior Stanislas |
Jordan Parkes | David Blackmore |
. | Freddie Sears |
. | . |
. | . |
For Reserves League table, click here